Closures mean neither "cops nor cop shops" in rural Scotland

Calum Steele, from South Uist,  is a former general secretary of the Scottish Police Federationplaceholder image
Calum Steele, from South Uist, is a former general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation

​News that the closure of police stations across Scotland continues apace would, once upon a time, have led to uproar. But such has been the systematic hollowing out of the physical, visible indications of a police presence across many of our communities that hardly an eyelid is batted anymore.

The latest figures identified by the 1919 magazine show a dozen more stations have closed their doors this year alone, and with a further 21 to follow in the near future, there are no signs the wrecking ball will be falling idle any time soon.

With an average of more than one police station closing every month since the Police Service of Scotland was created in 2014, the loss of over 180 buildings from which our constables and sergeants patrolled our towns and villages is stark – especially so for those communities in our most remote and rural corners of the country.

And whilst there are many questions to be asked about the political and policing choices made in respect of our national police service since 2014 (and I will return to some of them later), it would be downright dishonest to pretend the axe was not being wielded by the former forces and constabularies long before then too.

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - JULY 05: Police at the Palace of Holyroodhouse during a National Service of Thanksgiving and Dedication to the coronation of King Charles III and Queen Camilla at St Giles' Cathedral on July 5, 2023 in Edinburgh, Scotland. During the service of thanksgiving and dedication for the Coronation of King Charles III and Queen Camilla, the Honours of Scotland (the Scottish crown jewels) are presented to the new King. The service is based on a similar service held at St Giles' 70 years ago to mark the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II but unlike the 1953 service, the Stone of Destiny, on which ancient Scottish kings were crowned, will be present in the cathedral. (Photo by Robert Perry - Pool/Getty Images) : Police Scotland said they need a significant uplift in budget just to stand stillplaceholder image
EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - JULY 05: Police at the Palace of Holyroodhouse during a National Service of Thanksgiving and Dedication to the coronation of King Charles III and Queen Camilla at St Giles' Cathedral on July 5, 2023 in Edinburgh, Scotland. During the service of thanksgiving and dedication for the Coronation of King Charles III and Queen Camilla, the Honours of Scotland (the Scottish crown jewels) are presented to the new King. The service is based on a similar service held at St Giles' 70 years ago to mark the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II but unlike the 1953 service, the Stone of Destiny, on which ancient Scottish kings were crowned, will be present in the cathedral. (Photo by Robert Perry - Pool/Getty Images) : Police Scotland said they need a significant uplift in budget just to stand still

We need only look across Lewis and Harris to see that policing has, to all intents and purposes, been delivered from Stornoway for decades. Indeed, I may have been amongst the last men standing in what were termed the rural beats, when as far back as 2001 the fate of Tarbert, Balallan, Barvas, Carloway and Ness was being decided in Inverness.

And whilst neither I nor those colleagues who served in these stations at that time were the final occupants of these postings (at least on paper), we were amongst the last who were determined to serve each of those communities as our priority – and not merely as an afterthought for when Stornoway quietened down.

For all that, the pressure to leave our beats to service the demands in the town, particularly on a Friday and Saturday night, was severe, even as the then Northern Constabulary – which rightly and proudly boasted of its community-based ethos – began to subtly shift its attention away from what made it unique, to simply servicing the demands created by disorder.

The fact our island way of life was by and large law-abiding meant the reward for our honesty and integrity was to be punished for it. The preventative value of the local constable in keeping that good order was never really valued by the bosses who had stats to account for. Drunk driving and speeding were only really problems when they were detected, and as long as no one crashed, the letters of complaint could be ignored and would eventually peter out anyway.

The BBC hit series "Highland Cops" showed the challenges of policing rural communities -  a task made harder by the closure of 180 stations.placeholder image
The BBC hit series "Highland Cops" showed the challenges of policing rural communities - a task made harder by the closure of 180 stations.

Drug misuse is a scourge that exists everywhere and our islands have always been vulnerable to the risks and exploitation that such crimes bring. The overt reassurance that a police station signalled – a tangible commitment to a community – was being undermined as a “cops not cop shops” narrative was peddled; but ultimately it has proved to be neither cops nor shops as the retraction accelerated.

But for all that, there was at least an element of pretence that the local voices on the Northern Joint Police Board were being consulted in a meaningful way over the asset stripping happening under their very noses. Let us not forget that for the best part of two decades the deputy convenor or convenor of that board came from the Western Isles, and not one closure could they prevent.

Steeped, as many of us were, in the values of the communities that raised us, there remained a genuine desire to provide some form of surgery-based service in places that lost their physical police stations – not least as there were assurances given to justify their closures that such a thing would happen.

Slowly and predictably those early commitments drifted over time, and the community-based service was replaced by one determined purely by response. If something happened, the police would go. Otherwise, it was Stornoway all day long.

There is, however, no hiding place from the fact the decisions taken since 2014 have compounded what was, to steal a health analogy, an acute problem to the point it is now a chronic one. The unholy trinity of undervalue, underfund and undermine has been ruinous for remote and rural policing.

Whilst councils are notionally consulted on proposals to close police stations, not one of the 1,200-odd councillors in the country is properly able to grill the Chief Constable on why. I was far from a fan of the effectiveness of police boards, but the loss of all local voices from the scrutiny of policing decisions has proved to be an unmitigated disaster. Decisions that have a profound effect on communities are now reduced to a mere accounting exercise.

For all the fluff and bluster around the creation of our national police service, it was essentially a mechanism to save money. The original proposals upon which the plans were predicated suggested over £1 billion in the first ten years alone, but government couldn’t resist wringing more from the service and has taken more than twice that from the funding of our service.

Consecutive Chief Constables failed to make compelling cases against such swingeing cuts, and it was an inevitable consequence of squeezing the funding that the service simply could not afford to maintain its national footprint. The sheer scale of loss of stations is a stark indicator of how harsh those cuts have been.

Policing will always try to put the most positive spin it can on the challenges it faces. Terms like modern, responsive, technology, specialisms are all bandied about in an attempt to hide the realities – the service cannot cope.

What is being lost in all of this is not just brick and mortar but the very idea that a constable is a part of the community they serve. Rural Scotland has long been defined by trust, familiarity and a shared sense of responsibility for one another. When the police retreat, that social fabric thins.

If government will not redraw its priorities, then the quiet hollowing out of our communities will continue unchecked – and that damage will not easily be undone.

​

(Calum Steele is former general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation)

News you can trust since 1917
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice