50 years on – a radicalism that needs re-visited

Professor Jim Hunter speaking recently at a UHI conference in Dornoch.placeholder image
Professor Jim Hunter speaking recently at a UHI conference in Dornoch.

Not many books stay in print continuously for 50 years and even fewer have the authors still around to help celebrate the anniversary. The fact these norms have been broken by “The Making of the Crofting Community” and James Hunter speaks its own volumes about the significance of the work.

The 1970s was a time when the land issue in the Highlands and Islands was taken seriously and consciousness was stirred. The emergence of the West Highland Free Press, then “The Cheviot, the Stag and the Black, Black Oil”, John MacEwen’s momentous work to determine “Who Owns Scotland?”, the early days of Runrig were all contributors to that mix.

Long-buried stories had started to emerge. The burying had not been inadvertent. The history of Clearance and land struggle, if taught at all, was neutralised to the margins. It was possible to be educated in a Highland county and to study history in a Scottish university without being taught a word about either, as I can vouch. Awareness was acquired informally.

This was the world in which Jim Hunter grew up. “It all really goes back to my own upbringing in Duror”, he recalls. “My mother’s father, John Cameron, was born in 1872 and grew up in Strontian. He would have been one of the first generation to have gone to a state school. He was a great story teller and he lived into his 91st year”. The stories he told from that era made a great impression on a young mind.

The offices of Urras Oighreachd Ghabhsainn, the Galson Estate Trust, one of the few places to make community land ownership a realityplaceholder image
The offices of Urras Oighreachd Ghabhsainn, the Galson Estate Trust, one of the few places to make community land ownership a reality

“Then when I went to university in1967, to study history in Aberdeen, it was bearing in upon me that the received academic take on the 19th century Highlands and the Clearances was not in accord with what I had heard from my grandfather and my family more generally. There was a real divide”.

By the time he graduated and went to Edinburgh to work for his PhD, he was convinced that this was a void which needed filling. “What I was trying to do with the thesis originally was to produce an account of the 19th century that was academically reputable and simultaneously in accord with what people in the Highlands felt about their own history.

“One of my supervisors was John Bannerman, the son of the Liberal politician. He and I were actually distantly related through Tiree and Uist. The other influence on how I approached it was the then professor of history in Aberdeen, John Hargreaves, who had started his teaching career in Africa. I had done a course at Aberdeen which taught an African history of Africa.

“Until then all the history written about Africa was from a European perspective – colonisers, missionaries, explorers, merchants … It occurred to me that though the Highlands weren’t colonised in the way Africa was colonised, almost all of the history was written from government or estate records. What I was trying to do was put the crofters at the centre of their history”.

When “The Making of the Crofting Community” appeared, it was greeted with immediate interest and appreciation – but certainly not by Scotland’s most prominent historians, some of whom had long become committed to Clearance denial or, at best, serious under-statement and landlord apologia. I remember Scotland’s Historiographer Royal, Professor Gordon Donaldson of Edinburgh University, being particularly hostile – as they all had been towards John Prebble.

Jim Hunter recalls: “My book wasn’t reviewed in the Scottish Historical Review or any of the academic journals”. However, this was more than compensated for by “a glittering review by Sorley Maclean in the Times Literary Supplement”. Sorley described the book as “magnificent, marvellously comprehensive, just and profound”. Not surprisingly this quote has appeared on the cover of all subsequent reprints!

The more praise Jim’s book received, the more outraged the Scottish history establishment became. “Generally speaking, the comment about it by the established academics was negative”, he under-states. “A phrase they used was ‘one-sided’. I’m not sure what they thought their own stuff was”.

It wasn’t as if source material was unavailable for anyone who went looking. As Jim Hunter’s own experience confirmed, there had been first hand testimony available far into the 20th century while the evidence given to the Napier Commission in the 1880s added up to a stunning account of suffering, cruelty and eviction on an industrial scale. But in the ivory towers of Scotland’s universities, that too was dismissed as “one-sided’.

Jim says: “The other thing I was keen to do was to correct the version of history in which the story of the Clearances ended in cataclysmic defeat, which was striking a very pessimistic note. I was very keen to write about the land raids and Land League.

“It wasn’t a cataclysmic defeat. There was a fight back after it. That is why the book went on as far as land resettlement and land raids. I wanted to continue into the period after the First World War when there was so much agitation and a lot of land that had been taken out of crofting was put back. I don’t think a student doing a PhD now would get the chance to do that”.

Another historic weakness, says Jim, was that insofar as the Clearances had been written about at all, the focus was usually on Sutherland where the effects had been so extreme. At least in Sutherland, Patrick Sellar had a plan, however misguided. Elsewhere, the excesses of landlordism – like the Gordon of Cluny estates in Uist and Barra – were more “appalling” with little concern for whether the tenantry lived or died, or where they ended up.

“In the book there was quite a lot about the Outer Isles – both about the Clearances and what happened in the 1880s and thereafter. When I started this research I had never set foot in the Outer Isles but I have always believed that when you are writing the history of a place you should have at least been there. So, in1972, when I was a year into the research, I convinced Evelyn that our honeymoon should consist of a walking tour of Skye and the Outer Isles”.

Much of his research was done at the old Scottish Records Office in Edinburgh, searching through government records and estate papers, but familiarity with the places being written about contributed to his basic knowledge of what to look for. “At that point”, he says, “nothing at all had been written about the Clearances in Lewis and the resistance which took off there”.

By the 1880s, there was even less need to rely on estate papers since sections of the press had become active in the crofters’ cause, notably the Highland News and the Oban Times which was very much on the side of the Land League.

“It gave immensely detailed coverage to what was going on, on the ground. The other stuff available was government material on crofting which included detailed police reports on agitation and Land League meetings - who said what and what was said”. The coverage stretched from Islay up to Lewis and the paper was avidly read.

He says: “Another connection I tried to make which nobody had really touched before was the influence on the Highlands of what was going on in Ireland. There was a really close connection between the two land agitations. Michael Davitt in particular was very interested in the Highlands and had a close connection with John Murdoch”.

Jim’s researches made him a very regular visitor to the offices of the Oban Times which, by that time, was “very far from radical” and edited by Alan Cameron, son of Duncan, the original owner and editor. “He was always interested in what I was doing. He was simultaneously proud of what his father had accomplished but did not agree at all with the political outlook the paper had then”. That’s always the danger.

More likely to be invited to speak in village halls than into the ivory towers, Jim Hunter’s career course thereafter was far from orthodox. “At the time I graduated, there were no academic jobs anyway. We went back to Aberdeen and after a few months I got a one year contract with something called the Institute for the Study of Sparsely Populated Areas. That didn’t last long”.

Jim “drifted into journalism”. He reminds me: “I was very pleased to get a call from you to write a history column in the West Highland Free Press”. Then there was a staff job at the Press and Journal. When the Scottish Crofters Union was formed in 1985, its driving force, Angus ‘Ease’ Macleod, persuaded him to become its first director.

In 1998, despite the stiff resistance of civil servants which I recall well, he was appointed chairman of Highland and Islands Enterprise where he was able to maintain and strengthen its support for community land ownership. Subsequently, he chaired Scottish Natural Heritage and in 2005 became the first director of the School of History at the University of the Highlands and Islands, where he remains an Emeritus Professor. Throughout all this, he has continued a prodigious output of books with Highland themes.

In the 1970s, by telling the story of the past, “The Making of the Crofting Community” also fed into a mood that it was long past time to take land reform out the realms of history and make it part of a continuing story. Now, apart from the flurry of community buy-outs, most of them now more than 20 years ago, “it has virtually ground to a halt”.

In fact, says Jim Hunter, if you look at the whole of Scotland, it is actually going backwards with the concentration of ownership even more extreme. All this is tied up in the price of land and also an over-concentration on community ownership as synonymous with land reform – which it should not be.

The lessons are always in history. “It’s forgotten now”, he says, “how radical the 1921 Land Settlement Act was. It could oblige a private landlord to break up his estate whether he wanted to or not. That happened in Galson, for instance, much to Leverhulme’s disgust.

“The most recent acquisition of land for community ownership was Ulva and that cost £4 million. If places like Gigha or Eigg came on the market today, the price would be many millions rather than one or two. So meaningful land reform cannot rely entirely on community ownership.

“Even then, most of the community buy-outs were in crofting areas where there was a history of working together. That doesn’t really apply over most of rural Scotland or even the Highlands. The way to change lies in much more radical legislation, especially in taxation which could make an enormous difference.

“The legislation in 1886 or early 20th century – none of it fell from the sky. It was fought for – literally fought for. It does puzzle me a bit that given the problems there are across rural Scotland with housing and everything else, there isn’t more agitation on the ground to put pressure on government to link these issues to land.

“Something as basic as taking planning back to what existed after the Second World War would help. If government wanted to acquire land for development it could do it at existing use value. In real terms next to nothing”.

But where, we agree to wonder, does the political will or even interest exist to consider such measures. And 50 years on, we are also entitled to wonder - will it ever? At least, the history will always be there.

News you can trust since 1917
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice