Island shops hit back at “Spotty Bag” from Banff​

Local traders are angry that a place has been reserved for a mainland-based firm which sells produce already available hereplaceholder image
Local traders are angry that a place has been reserved for a mainland-based firm which sells produce already available here

Stornoway business owners are up in arms about a decision to allow a mainland bargain retailer to sell its wares in the Town Hall in the run-up to Christmas.

Hard-pressed shopkeepers on the island are concerned that the Spotty Bag Shop’s pop-up will impact on their vital festive trade.

The Banff based business have been issuing leaflets in the community, advertising their arrival.

The Stornoway Traders Group have met with Comhairle nan Eilean Siar to voice their concerns and are hopeful that the agreement with the Spotty Bag Shop will be rescinded.

The town hall markets are very popular, particularly in the run-up to Christmasplaceholder image
The town hall markets are very popular, particularly in the run-up to Christmas

Emma Campbell-Macleod of the Good Food Boutique told the Gazette: “I'm annoyed about it, to be honest. There's nothing in that market you can't buy anywhere else in town.

"Obviously, coming in the run-up to Christmas, this is when we're all trying to make our money.

“I feel it’s a bit of a kick in the teeth for everybody. Some people will feel it more than others”.

The Banff-based Spotty Bag Shop sells everything from cosmetics to cleaning products, DIY goods, toys, sweets and much more.

Speaking for the Stornoway Traders’ Group, Iain Faller of the Island Spirit Whisky Shop said: “They will be selling gift bags, Christmas cards, stocking fillers, sweets and treats, winter clothing, accessories and hampers. 


"Within a very short radius of the Town Hall itself, you've got all that getting sold.

"Baltic Bookshop, Argos, Nicholson, Sardar, Events … you've also got the garden centres a wee bit further away and they will all feel the impact.

"Basically, we've got local businesses that pay into the system and contribute to the local economy.”

Iain continued: “Everybody's in the same boat. They rely on Christmas sales to get them through till Easter. It goes dead in January and February's not much better.

"In March, you get a few people trickling through but it's really April before you pick up again.

“It's a dark, hard winter for many businesses, and they rely on the festive trade. It could be 25 or 30 per cent of their annual turnover.

"For a business to come here from Banff, of all places, selling their wares for a few days, taking the money and leaving the island, without putting anything back into the local economy, is so wrong. So we’re trying to get it stopped”.

Mr Faller said he had raised the issue with Comhairle nan Eilean Siar who have agreed to review their letting policy.

“I’ve been given assurances that everybody sympathised with our concerns," he said.

“I will report back to the Stornoway Traders group that the Comhairle are going to take action if possible.”

Speaking to the Gazette, Des Cheyne, owner of The Spotty Bag Shop, said that it was “never our intention to cause ill feeling with some of the traders in Stornoway”.

He said that during a visit back in August they “were asked by the public to come back up before Christmas and we chose November as opposed to December to avoid having an impact on Christmas sales in December”.

“With the range we took up, albeit some things may have crossed over, we had products that we have imported in from different countries from across the globe so we felt it was good to showcase this and give the residents an opportunity to purchase these,” he added.

“The feedback we received was that we had given everyone more choice, availability and affordability, saying that it was allowing their money to go further.”

Mr Cheyne said they were also “disappointed” at the notion that they were “taking all the money off the island”.

“We worked out that the last two trips cost approximately £14,000 between air bnbs, ferry costs, the hire of the hall, restaurants, takeaways, local shops for gifts to take back home and fuel for the vehicles,” he added.

“I would have thought by encouraging more people like us onto the island it would allow the town centre to become a bustling town centre outwith the tourist season but also let people see that the traders are as friendly and welcoming as the residents are.

"We were ever so grateful with our time in Stornoway, even if it may have ruffled a few feathers among some local retailers, however communities should be allowed to evolve, welcome new opportunities and embrace change for everyone to flourish."

News you can trust since 1917
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice