A cultural leniency that enables damaging behaviour

Eve was motivated to study the subject after seeing the damage first handplaceholder image
Eve was motivated to study the subject after seeing the damage first hand

​​Growing up in Barvas in the north of Lewis, a crofting community on the edge of the Atlantic, Eve Crawford was well aware of the painful and damaging impacts from a life of addiction.

It was something that affected her own family directly and as she grew to become more aware of her wider cultural environment, realised they were far from alone: substance abuse, primarily alcohol, was all-pervasive, an accepted and sometimes corrosive element in an otherwise supportive community.

The scourge of alcoholism in rural communities goes back decades if not centuries, a sense of remoteness and isolation only seeming to contribute to the psychological predilection to pursue a behaviour which can all too easily – and often without warning – turn deeply damaging, not only to the individual concerned but also their loved ones.

As Eve surveyed all around her, and fuelled by her own personal experience, she was driven to understand more, pursuing her academic studies, first in psychology, and now publishing a masters dissertation from Stirling University: “Exploring Perceived Leniency Towards Alcohol and Substance Use in Lewis and Harris”.

A culture of acceptance leaves it more challenging to address.placeholder image
A culture of acceptance leaves it more challenging to address.

The aim was to ascertain and quantify the effects of a culture of acceptance, not just in normalising damaging behaviour, but whether that wider societal pressure acts as a barrier in getting crucial help to those who need it.

“I’ve always been interested in psychology and the brain and why people do what they do,” she said. “I had family members affected by drug and alcohol addiction. When I was doing my under-graduate degree in Glasgow (Strathclyde University) I volunteered with the Connect charity who help people with rehab and do a lot of community support. I was blown away with the work they do and that sparked my interest even more.”

Explaining a bit more about her own personal circumstances she said that seeing what happened to her foster brother “honed my eyes from quite a young age”.

“Both my parents are teachers and I got lots of stories from them about different kids from different backgrounds and areas and really thought about this underlying theme of drugs and alcohol and how it plays such a big role.

“When I got older I just thought: you never want any child to experience that and I thought what can I do about it.”

Her dissertation has now been published and its results are illuminating, if not hugely surprising for anyone with a familiarity of island communities. It was based on an online questionnaire, which Eve herself states in the report does have its limitations in terms of quantitative credibility.

But with 262 responses from local residents garnered in all, it is a decent representative sample. The fact that the majority are from the younger age demographic only reinforces its value.

It concludes that “on Lewis and Harris, perceived leniency was widespread for high-risk alcohol use but contested for high-risk substance use, showing why local context and the type of substance matter”.

“Alcohol appears to occupy a distinctive cultural position within Lewis and Harris”, it adds, but with illegal drugs it is “far more divisive and is possibly substance specific”.

The findings, said the report, “suggested that leniency was understood through normalisation, tolerance, non-intervention, concealment and the protection of social relationships”.

The different attitudes found towards illegal substances “highlight the importance of culturally specific approaches to rural drug-use and suggest that urban-centred models may not fully capture community processes operating in remote Scottish settings and warrant further research across rural Scotland”.

As the dissertation explores, part of the justification for the research was that so much of the data that currently exists centres on urban areas with so much less information available for rural communities, and even less that is island specific.

“This study adds community-level evidence from Lewis and Harris by combining quantitative and qualitative insight, not simply measuring prevalence,” said the report.

“The findings considered alongside existing literature add to the notion that rural contexts can involve different issues around anonymity, accessibility, infrastructure and community relationships.

“Further research is needed to determine whether these patterns are unique to Lewis and Harris or reflect wider rural Scottish processes.”

​

​

What now for Eve?

With her dissertation now complete and an impressive body of work behind her, she is able to take something of a breath and reflect – if only for a brief moment.

Now the world of work awaits and, to boot, she is busy preparing for her upcoming nuptials. “It’s a Siarach marrying a Rubhach so goodness knows how that will go,” she jokes.

She was in the fortunate position that having graduated from Strathclyde University, she was able to move home and do the masters from Stirling University remotely, which certainly helped in terms of cost.

“It was all online which was pretty handy,” she said. “I was able to move home and get a job and do all my course work and class work online. I’m going down at the end of this month for my graduation which is a bit surreal having never been on the actual campus.

"I suppose one of the good things of Covid was that I was able to be up here and work and study, live at home and not have to pay too much rent.”

She worked in the Hub Cafe at Willowglen while doing the dissertation and in July started with the local rehab charity Hebrides Alpha, something which was very close to her heart – “a dream masters and dream career all working into one”.

“I don’t know what the future holds, not sure where we’ll end up, but I’ll definitely stay in this line of work and I really see the need for it up here,” she said. “But for now my place is with Hebrides Alpha.”

The million dollar question, as Eve readily admits (and in fairness was not something she aimed to address in the dissertation) is what drives one person to be an alcoholic, the other to be a happy, contented social drinker and the other embracing abstinence.

The truth is there probably isn’t one, or at least one that can be explained within easily defined parameters.

“It can be a wee bit of nature and a wee bit of nurture,” she theorises herself. “There are arguments across the field as to whether you are born with an addictive personality or is it a learnt behaviour.

“We would say at Hebrides Alpha that recovery is an individual journey for everyone and therefore it’s logical that addiction has to be an individual journey for everyone.

“For some people it can be linked to mental health issues, so that when they use substances they feel less depressed or find joy or derive a confidence boost from it. For some it can be something that was in the household a lot and just not known anything different.

“Up here there's definitely a sense of: ‘Och it’s what we do, boys will be boys, it’s a Saturday, come on we’re all out to the Rangers Club or Macneills’.

“That can very quickly grow arms and legs and before people know it, what started out as a Friday night activity, becomes an all-week thing. But I would definitely say it has a fair bit to do with the culture you’re in.

“You’ll have seen from the results of the dissertation that specifically alcohol is treated very leniently up here but with drugs it’s a bit different.

"People know it’s going on and quite that it’s widespread – certainly we absolutely see that at Hebrides Alpha – but it’s treated differently. So there’s a lot of work to be done and a lot of lives to be helped and, overdoses to be prevented.”

If you or someone you know is struggling with addiction or substance abuse help is out there. Crisis services are available via Western Isles Hospital (01851 704704) or there are various voluntary organisations in our area, including Hebrides Alpha. Crisis services are also available at the Western Isles Alcohol and Drug Crisis Service. The Substance Misuse Nursing Service can be contacted at 01851 763305 (Lewis & Harris team) or 01870 603279 (Uists & Barra Team). You can also access Drinkline, tel. 0300 123 1110

News you can trust since 1917
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice