Bernera groups face financial ruin from legal costs


A second Bernera community organisation is facing financial ruin due to the activities of Claire Kellerman, an American woman who has been involved in multiple altercations with businesses on Lewis, mainly over rights of access for her dog.
At Stornoway Sheriff Court last week, a case raised by Ms Kellerman via the publicly-funded Ethnic Minorities Law Centre in Glasgow, was continued for legal debate in December piling further costs upon Bernera Community Association.
As previously revealed by the Gazette, Ms Kellerman’s action was originally directed against Bernera Community Development Trust, a small charity which has nothing to do with the community café which was at the centre of Ms Kellerman’s complaint about her dog not being admitted.
The Development Trust ran up legal costs of over £7000 before Kellerman’s agents admitted in court that the action was directed against the wrong organisation. At that point, it was amended in order to sue Bernera Community Association, which runs the café on a voluntary basis, for £10,000.
The Association, which provides many community services on Bernera, confirmed this week that it faces potential bankruptcy if legal costs continue to mount. Already, normal fund-raising efforts are being diverted into legal fees to contest Ms Kellerman’s action.
Much of the frustration felt by victims of her behaviour is directed towards the Scottish Legal Aid Board which has continued to underwrite Ms Kellerman’s activities – in spite of being told in advance of the initial case that it was directed against the wrong party. They then allowed the legal aid certificate to be transferred to her revised action.
While costs were awarded to Bernera Community Development Trust, this was of no value since the fact she benefits from Legal Aid protects Ms Kellerman from payment of costs.
This week, in response to questions from Gazette, the Scottish Legal Aid Board said that no payments have yet been made to the Ethnic Minorities Law Centre who are representing Ms Kellerman.
They said:“We have carefully reviewed the matter at a senior level and can confirm that the application was handled thoroughly, properly and entirely in line with all legal aid rules and guidance.
“All potentially relevant information was provided and considered as part of our assessment of the application, including in relation to the applicant’s financial circumstances. Solicitors have a duty to report to us if anything happens as a case progresses that might be relevant to the continuing grant of legal aid”.
Asked if the case had been drawn to the attention of the quango’s board, they replied: “The Chair is aware of the previous press coverage in relation to this case. However, our board (and Chair) have no role in relation to decision-making on individual cases such as this”.
Following a meeting with Bernera Community Association’s advisers, Donald Mackinnon MSP has written to the Scottish Legal Aid Board, asking for an “urgent review” of their position and pointing to the reputational issues the case gives rise to.
Mr Mackinnon wrote: “ This case raises broader concerns about the safeguards applied when public funds are used to support litigation. Legal aid serves an important role in ensuring access to justice. However, it is equally important that publicly funded litigation is subject to appropriate scrutiny regarding its legal basis, prospects of success and overall reasonableness”.
He questioned the “reasonableness” about continuing to provide legal aid cover in this case. “It is a matter of concern that a review of basic information was not pursued, such as publicly available documents and Companies House records, which would have confirmed that GBCDT was an erroneously named party.
“As a consequence of this, GBCDT incurred legal costs with considerable stress and diversion of time and resources from its charitable and community activities.
I am further concerned by the decision to permit the continuation of legal aid following extensive amendment of the writ.
“My understanding is that the original writ was amended on numerous occasions and ultimately substituted a different defender, namely Bernera Community Association. This would constitute not a minor procedural amendment but a fundamental change to the identity of the party being sued. Notwithstanding this substantial alteration, the legal aid certificate was apparently permitted to continue in support of the amended action”.
This week, the Gazette spoke to several Stornoway business owners and operators who have been on the receiving end of Ms Kellerman’s alleged behaviour. A common pattern emerged of her shouting at staff, threatening legal action, using abusive language and insisting on her right to bring her dog onto premises.
In two cases, we were told of staff being reduced to tears and one business owner told us they had considered closing the premises in order to avoid a repetition of a deeply upsetting experience.
The businesses we spoke to expressed great sympathy for the people on Bernera but feared that if they “put our head above the parapet” they too could end up on the receiving end of a legal action they could not afford to defend.
Ms Kellerman arrived in Lewis about four years ago. She comes from a privileged background in California where her aunt, and adoptive mother, was Sally Kellerman, who played the part of “Hot Lips Houlihan” in the film “MASH”.