Patients turning down treatment due to costs


No review of the £60 a limit on overnight accommodation payments for patients has yet been started – more than three and a half years after it was promised by Scottish Government Ministers.
This week, the Health Secretary, Angela Constance, provided the Gazette with a statement which implied that it is within the powers of the Western Isles NHS Board to make higher payments if they choose.
However, this appears to contradict Scottish Government guidance which states that under the Highlands and Islands Patient Travel Scheme, bed and breakfast is reimbursed at “up to £60 a night”.
The continuing confusion comes amid increasing concerns that some island patients are failing to take up vital appointments which involve travel away from home because they cannot afford the costs.
Na h-Eileanan an Iiar MP, Torcuil Crichton, described the situation as “farcical”. He said: “While Sottish Government and Health Board quibble about who can do what, the reality is that nothing has changed in years and patients are suffering as a result”.
Mr Crichton said: “When we held meetings recently about the health crisis in Uist and Barra, this was one of the issues that came up repeatedly. It has got to the point for some patients that they have to consider turning down appointments on the mainland, or in Stornoway.
“People are telling us they are not referring themselves because they cannot face the arduous journey to hospital in Stornoway or Inverness. They are paying out of their own pockets to get access to the NHS and struggling with inadequate overnight allowances.
“It’s the simplest thing the Western Isles Health Board could do – raise the allowance to realistic levels”.
The statement provided in Ms Constance’s name said: “Health Boards are responsible for developing their own policies, using Scottish Government guidance on entitlement to patient travel expenses and overnight accommodation expenses where applicable.
“I recognise this guidance requires review and have committed to doing so in consultation with island communities and within the context of wider reform of access to care. Work to finalise the scope of this review is ongoing”.
The review was first promised in April 2023 by the then Public Health Minister, Jenny Minto.
On Monday, following receipt of Ms Constance’s response, the Gazette asked the Health Board for comment but no reply had been received as we went to press.
Isles MSP Donald Mackinnon said: “The current rate is set at £60 which will not go very far in Inverness Glasgow or indeed Stornoway for patients travelling from Uist and Barra.
“We are supposed to have a universal healthcare system free at the point of use but here we have island residents having to stump up large amounts of cash to access NHS services. That is shameful and I will continue to pursue this issue with the Scottish Government.”
When he raised the subject at Holyrood, Mr Mackinnon quoted a case in which a constituent who spent a month in Inverness receiving radiotherapy faced accommodation costs of £2700 but was eligible to claim only £1500.
The lowest hotel rate for basic accommodation in Glasgow is around £130 per night while the overnight accommodation allowance for MSPs is £242.
MEANWHILE, Cllr Uisdean Robertson has stepped up his criticism of the Health Board for failing to reduce the need for patient travel from Uist and Barra by sending more clinicians from Stornoway.
In a letter to CalMac's area manager, he writes: "My concern is that CalMac is reshaping the mainland lifeline service on which Uist depends around a set of NHS requirements that remains insufficiently defined, while we see little evidence of a comparable effort by NHS Western Isles to restore and improve clinical delivery in Uist and Barra".