MSP’s plea for marine energy body rebuffed


The Scottish Government’s energy minister, Stephen Gethins MSP, has said that commercialisation of wave or tidal energy is “not a near-term prospect”. He was defending the decision to defund Wave Energy Scotland which operates within Highlands and Islands Enterprise.
At one time, the Western Isles was seen as being in the forefront of marine energy developments but this has been overtaken in recent years by the focus on offshore wind.
Mr Gethins was responding to a short debate initiated by Donald Mackinnon in which the Western Isles MSP described withdrawal of support from Wave Energy Scotland as “an enormous mistake and an act of vandalism that should be reversed”.
He thanked “three constituents who work for Wave Energy Scotland who have taken the time to meet me to help me to understand the situation that we now find ourselves in”.
However, Mr Gethins responded: “Against a backdrop of constrained budgets, we must take difficult decisions about how limited resources are prioritised, and although Wave Energy Scotland has long-term potential, commercialisation is not a near-term prospect”.
Mr Mackinnon told MSPs: “Since its establishment in 2014, Wave Energy Scotland has been a success story. It has supported 132 projects, which have all been delivered on budget, and, importantly, it has been able to keep European money flowing into Scottish projects.
“I am seriously concerned that the expertise, experience and institutional knowledge developed through Wave Energy Scotland is at risk of being lost, and with it our ability to continue to support that all-important innovation, research and development. At the moment, the signals that the Government is giving are that Scotland is not interested in wave and tidal energy.”
Highlands and Islands Green MSP, Kristopher Leask, said: “Progress on the development of a scaled-up marine energy sector is within touching distance, but the Scottish and UK Governments must now make a conscious choice.
“They must decide whether they want to have a world-leading marine energy sector or not. Policy certainty, funding stability and political leadership are now crucial, especially when the broader energy sector in Scotland faces such uncertainty.”
Orkney LibDem MSP, Liam McArthur, concurred: “More than ever, we need a clear statement of intent from the Government that gives the sector the confidence and support that it needs. The Scottish Government’s announced intention to withdraw funding from Wave Energy Scotland at the beginning of the year sent the opposite message”.
He added: “Scottish Renewables continues to emphasise its call for a statement of policy intent. We are at a critical juncture for the commercialisation of the sector and need clear leadership from the Scottish Government”.
A task force, backed by UK, Scottish and Welsh governments, was set up earlier this year to advise on the future of the marine energy sector.
Mr Gethins said: “Realising the full potential of marine energy requires continued collaboration between the Government, industry, academia and delivery partners. I look forward to publication of the recommendations of the Marine Energy Task Force”.